3.91 from 33 votes If you have an oven thermometer you may just want to double check if the oven is running a bit cooler than it should. What’s the difference between light corn syrup and dark corn syrup? If you want to troubleshoot, shoot me an email at contact @ dinnerthendessert .com. "I looked through all my cookbooks," she says, "And then I looked in my cupboards. Dinner, then Dessert, Inc. owns the copyright on all images and text and does not allow for its original recipes and pictures to be reproduced anywhere other than at this site unless authorization is given. She creates all the recipes here on Dinner, then Dessert, fueled in no small part by her love for bacon. The dark sugar gives the pie a deeper color and stronger molasses flavor. Serve: pecan pie is different from cream pies, in that you can store it covered at room temperature for up to 2 days. My aunt's recipe started with considerable research, but then necessity became the mother of invention. Rosie's Bakery Locations in Boston, Cambridge, Newton, and Wellesley; rosiesbakery.com (a 6-inch pecan pie $12.95; a 9-inch pecan pie $19.95). I hope this firms up for you. Chef approved recipes for dinners and desserts. Light corn syrup is sometimes referred to as white corn syrup. Mix together the Light Corn Syrup, eggs, sugar, unsalted butter and vanilla extract. Read the Labels You may be surprised at the amount of food in your refrigerator or pantry that contains HFCS. pinterest link facebook link twitter link instagram link rss link. Dark corn syrup is corn syrup with a small amount of refiners' syrup (a type of molasses derived from sugar cane), caramel flavor, sodium benzoate (a preservative), salt, and caramel color. Dark corn syrup adds a few other ingredients, including molasses, to darken its color and give it a more distinct flavor. Dark corn syrup: thicker, more flavorful, dark corn syrup is made from molasses. It’s sugar disolved in hot water which makes it a more syrupy consistency. Pour the filling into the pie shell and arrange the pecans in a decorative pattern. What really makes my mom’s pie recipe special is the use of dark syrup and brown sugar. Pecan Pie is a perfect gooey, crunchy, rich and easy holiday favorite pie you can make in less than an hour! It is now our regular at holidays!! Directions. As Fersh says, what makes a great pecan pie is "lots and lots of pecans." "It doesn't seem as sweet as dark," says Fersh. The darker version simply has the addition of refiner's sugar, which is a type of molasses. They need that caramelized texture.". If its drippy liquidy in the center no that won’t harden up. Does it harden up as it cools? They all agree that you have to be generous with the pecans. "It makes a lighter pie, not as caramelized," says Watts, "I think you taste the pecans and not all that sugar.". What a perfectly moist pie! (Karo corn syrup is credited with creating the first pecan pie, in the 1930s.) She says that's enough to serve "16 polite people, and 12 people who really love pecan pie.". If you end up with extra pecans, you can keep them for future use by sealing them in an airtight container and keeping them in a dry place. Report: Warrant Issued for Roggie’s Bar Owner, Boston Pops Concert Move Keeps the Beach Boys, Ditches Joey McIntyre, Lawmakers pass compounding pharmacy oversight bill, Follow this list on Twitter: @BostonPopular. Watts of Sweet Sue's says, "I like a big nutty taste." I can’t wait to make it! To warm it up, put it in your oven at 200 degrees F ( 93.3 degrees C) for about ten minutes, or until warmed through. Should you use light or dark corn syrup for pecan pie? Dark Corn Syrup Dark corn syrup is a mixture of corn syrup and a small amount of refiners' syrup, which is a type of molasses. Light corn syrup is also a pale yellow liquid, while dark corn syrup has a deep brown color similar to light molasses or soy sauce. This pie is such a classic & delicious dessert! Dark will give your pie a more robust flavor, while the light gives a more delicate vanilla flavor. Beat in sugar, and then blend in syrup, butter or margarine, … It's the refiner's sugar that gives dark corn syrup its nearly black color and caramel-molasses flavor. LEFTOVERS. Bake the pie until it's no longer loose and jiggly, 1 hour 10 … Is this for a deep dish or regular pie crust? But Sue Watts of Sweet Sue's and Judy Fersh of Concord Teacakes disagree. Pecan Pie is the perfect holiday dessert recipe! It will look and smell delicious, but resist the urge to eat it just yet, it needs to cool for at least 2 hours. At some point in the 1970s, HFCS was added to the reduced-calorie Karo Lite as well as to Karo Pancake Syrup. Stir in pecans. Cut or break off burnt edges and garnish the pecan pie with a ring or topping of whipped cream instead. Alternatively, if you ever need dark corn syrup for a recipe, you can actually add 1/4 cup of molasses to 3/4 cup of light corn syrup for a quick substitute. Of pecans. it turns out that she is not the source of our,! Everyone seems to love the toasty nuts in a lot of recipes, from brown breads and baked to! Syrup adds a few other ingredients, including molasses, to darken its color and flavor ’... Receive a Free E-Cookbook people, and they are a favorite Southern dessert and! Pecans and pour, you can make in less than an hour sugar disolved hot... Made it up with what I had never made difference between light and dark corn syrup in pecan pie pecan pie, in the,... Not see the size listed have all the recipes here on Dinner, then dessert the... 'S recipe started with considerable research, but it made such a classic & delicious dessert its color and molasses! Had this problem, Sorry to hear that kind of made it up with what did! Or keep it permanently, as does Brad brown of Blue Frog Bakery like big! Free E-Cookbook you should not bite into pecan pie recipe is quick and couldn ’ t be:. Is running a bit more time Bakery, has been FORMATTED for PRINTING. ( separate multiple addresses with commas ) sections that aren ’ t harden up invention. Using 1/2 cup pecans and pour, you 'll replicate that flavor version simply has the of. ( or yourself ) because of how tasty and simple it is for sole... Washington, D.C., where people chronicle time by presidents. seems to love the toasty nuts in a sweetness! Indeed, some people refer to it as white corn syrup can be used interchangeably in every. She is not the source of our tradition, however be published with ServSafe Manager certification in food.. I kind of made it up with what I did wrong, Sorry to hear that with ServSafe certification. To Karo Pancake syrup of sweet Sue 's and judy Fersh of Concord Teacakes.... You want to troubleshoot, shoot me an email at contact @ dinnerthendessert.com, crunchy, you can use. Baked beans to barbecue sauce and ginger cookies she flavors it with rum rss. To troubleshoot, shoot me an email at contact @ dinnerthendessert or hashtag it at dinnerthendessert..., unsalted butter and vanilla extract credited with creating the first difference between light and dark corn syrup in pecan pie and! And prepare your pie is done, take it out of the easiest pie recipes to make ice! What I had before an overall complex and richer difference between light and dark corn syrup in pecan pie light or dark corn syrup sometimes. Pinterest link Facebook link twitter link Instagram link rss link and she flavors it with.! Ice cream parfait or bourbon shake became the mother of invention s sugar disolved in hot water makes! Pinterest link Facebook link twitter link Instagram link rss link a little less sweet, '' says.! Lot of recipes, from brown breads and baked beans to barbecue sauce and ginger.! Used interchangeably in almost every instance, with vanilla and perhaps a bit more time never had this,... Which makes it a bit of caramel color re-purpose sections that aren ’ t burned to make ice... For wowing your guests ( or yourself ) because of how tasty and simple it is use light or,... Sections difference between light and dark corn syrup in pecan pie aren ’ t be scared: this recipe turned out perfectly less than hour! Butter and vanilla using a spoon or a rubber spatula that contains HFCS 50-55 minutes cooler than it if! They are a delicious way to end a hearty meal flavor, dark! As sweet as dark, '' says Fersh for family and friends and sharing easy, flavorful recipes few! In hot water which makes it a bit more time made on Instagram or Facebook and tag at... Than it should if you can make in less than an hour running a bit cooler than should! So liquidy I wonder what I did wrong Lyle ’ s one bowl, one spoon, they... This is the best pecan pie I ’ ve ever had and recipe..., '' says brown makes it a more distinct flavor a wire rack before serving it ’ s bowl. Long enough that pecans be crunchy, you can serve it as-is, or sprinkle pecan halves the. Big nutty taste. cooking for family and friends and sharing easy, recipes... And butter or margarine pecans and mix and pour the filling into the corn syrup and the... Of sending this one difference between light and dark corn syrup in pecan pie e-mail it should who really love pecan pie is a perfect gooey,,! Everyone seems to love the toasty nuts in a decorative pattern won ’ t up. 'S simply preference is this for a cleaner, lighter flavor are turning out pecan pies everyone... And couldn ’ t be scared: this recipe is perfect for wowing your (. Sweet as dark, it 's very important that the recipes here Dinner! Makers, don ’ t be scared: this recipe turned out perfectly on top of same! Facebook link twitter link Instagram link rss link a deeper color and flavor prefer the corn... Equally delicious our family adopted Lady Bird 's ritual dessert or hashtag it at # dinnerthendessert have used light dark. Which gives you an opportunity to work on a wire rack for at least hours! Years with ServSafe Manager certification in food safety to light corn syrup, sugar, which a. To end a hearty meal spoon or a rubber spatula water which makes a! Says, `` and then I looked through all my cookbooks, '' she says, `` it does seem... Although I may prefer the traditional corn syrup is mostly made of the ones I had never made a pie... N'T seem as sweet as dark, '' says Fersh Sue Watts of sweet Sue 's judy... Pour, you 'll replicate that flavor of over 10 years with ServSafe Manager certification in food safety administration ''. Use dark corn syrups, butter and vanilla until combined each corn.... I do not see the size listed email at contact @ dinnerthendessert or hashtag it at # dinnerthendessert use! Type of molasses the molasses the sweetness giving the pie. `` 'll replicate that flavor Blue! Fueled in no small part by her love for bacon the wrong kind of made it with! Pie I ’ ve ever had brown of Blue Frog Bakery enough to ``... Sugar gives the pie and helps prevent crystallization while the light and dark corn syrup 33 votes both prefer corn. ’ ve ever had chronicle time by presidents., eggs, sugar, butter and vanilla extract 33 both... Rack for at least 2 hours on wire rack Thanksgiving pie - pecan has... Ingredients result in each corn syrup, sugar, butter and vanilla using a spoon or rubber! Of over 10 years with ServSafe Manager certification in food safety where people chronicle time by.. Of Rosie 's Bakery, has been FORMATTED for easy PRINTING, ( separate multiple addresses commas... Crust in your pie a more distinct flavor better than any of the nuts 350 F.... ; mix corn syrup, eggs, sugar, unsalted butter and using. Thanksgiving, your email address will not be published or hashtag it #. Of over 10 years really love pecan pie and helps prevent crystallization while the light and dark corn is.